Underscores - U
It should probably be said that Underscores's previous album Wallsocket is one of my favorite albums of all time and is easily a 10/10 for me.
Which means my expecations going into this new album from April Harper Grey were probably too high. Upon my first listen, I was a bit underwhelmed. A lot of the rock edge that was all over her previous two albums Fishmonger and Wallsocket are less present here in favor of a more "main pop girl" type sound, the hooks weren't as catchy as Wallsocket, it didn't have that moment from Uncanny Long Arms where it drop the 2nd verse from Kinko's Field Trip 2006 and I lose my god damn mind (and yes I'm aware she took that part from the demo track Inlaws but that became Kinko's Field Trip 2006 and that's the version that's more readily available;) i just wasn't feeling it at first. Well thank fucking god for repeated listens. Cause after the intial feeling of \"This isn't just Wallsocket 2!" wore off and I started seeing some of my peers talking about how much they loved the album, I was able to relisten to the album and meet it where it is, it's Underscores showing she has the capacity to be in the "Main Pop Girl" conversation and I'm here for it. I was always here for it. I've been following April's career since her with Sleepycatt at Mine Gala back in 2019 and I still play that set on repeat... jesus christ 7 years later????? Time is evil. Anyways, She's been on a pretty amazing run since she dropped her Character Development EP back in 2020 and has been doing some truly wonderful and weird stuff with Six Impala that I hope continues along with her rising profile as a solo artist. Which is a lot of words to say she has been putting in the work for years now and it's been so gratifying to see that work pay off
Which brings us to U. Her latest album. It kicks off with Tell Me (U Want It) which itself kicks off with a brief beat that I can only describe as "hookah lounge core" though I say that with love. It then moves into a more guitar-driven beat that has been a staple of her work on past albums. Lyrically here April is telling us she's got some new ideas she's trying out but you gotta tell her if you want it or not. Given the more pop focused production of the album it's an easy read to see this as April pondering the next steps in her career and hoping she's not gonna alienate her old fanbase with the new direction. Sure that's a pretty obvious topic for your first pop record but April pulls it off with solid production and a dubstep drop of a chorus that reminds you she's a huge Skrillex fan and that he's also putting out some great music recently. After that we go right into Music which was the lead single off the album and easily my favorite track. It begins with a stuttering beat that I swore her former roommate Umru made since they have been working together recently but nope, this whole record is her except for the album artwork and the mastering on Music. The first actual lyrics to this track are April telling us "Last night, I had a wet dream bout the perfect song" with that ever important "wet" being said with pretty little fanfare, it's flirty sure but there's that level of subdued normality to it that really highlights April's songwritiing. The songwriting helps greatly here because if you're gonna write a song about how being around someone feels like music then the music itself needs to be good enough to be believable, and I'm on board 100% here. The aforementioned stuttering beat and casually yet flirtatiously delivered lyrics portray a girl talking up her crush and for the most part is playing it effortlessly smooth except she just can't help herself from occasionally throwing in a line or two that reveals how flustered she really is (she says their words sound like God at one point, been there girl.) Not only that but the build in the song has the instant earworm of "Pop, rock, electronic, rap, rock n' roll Nonstop, avant-garde, talkin' on the phone" which gradually builds up until it finally bursts through with the "We Don't Give A Fu-" sample she previous had used on Gunk that goes just, so fucking hard.
Next up is Hollywood Forever which is a perfectly servicable pop song with a very 2010's club turn about half way through that gets just, sooooooo close to turning into a Six Impala track but never quite makes that leap unforunately. Next up is another highlight of the album The Peace which refers to a Japanese cigarette brand and talks about keeping up a cigarette habit to keep things peaceful with a partner. It's beat is centered around some cut up bits of multi-tracked and vocoded vocals that create an almost Imgoen Heap like vibe blanketing over the track. It's whistful and shy and a quieter track that even with it's gradual build never quite launches but in a way that feels less like it failed to launch and more like it's intentionally holding itself back to mirror the lyrics that have April realizing she would rather just enjoy the moments she gets to spend with this person than change the dynamic by making a move.
Innuendo (I Get U) and Lovefield are next and I don't really have much to say about them other than I like them. Following that however is Do It which is a club ready jam about attempting to build a relationship when you're career is taking off and you are no longer super sure where you're gonna be in 5 years. There's a boost of swagger in Grey's vocal delivery here that makes the whole track feel like it's both a serious conversation about relationships and a buisness deal that all takes place in the middle of the club. April makes an attempt here to act like a big shot towards this potential new partner ask them about rough sex, if they would be okay with her leaving for months at a time without contact, saying she doesn't actually fall in love with people; only for the second verse to drop the floor out from under her as the partner ask her about how much money she makes and if they are going to have songs written about how good or bad they are in bed. Neither side seems to be really happy about the situation but can't quite shake how good it would make them feel which leads to everything stalling out. Lyrically that is, the instrumentation here is begging to be played at the club and sounds as tight as ever.
The album closes out with Bodyfeeling a solid track that whips a distroted guitar around a headbangable beat in another song about being around your lover. It closes out with Wish U Well which is a slower more acoustic track and usually the point on the Underscores album where she's gets intropective (see Del Mar County Fair 2008 off of Fishmonger and Good Luck Final Girl off of Wallsocket) and while this one gets gets a bit more of a beat to it than the previous two songs I mentioned, it still feels like the end of the album. The party is winding down, the relationship she's been trying to start is now fading as the two parties must go their sepreate ways, and we're just seeing what memories and moments we can grab onto before they leave. For her third album overall and second one under her Corporate Rockmusic sublabel of Mom + Pop, she's at the stage of her career where she's starting to gain some real traction, she's good friends with current indie darling Jane Remover, she's showing up on Porter Robinson remixes, getting features on Pitchfork, and opening for Charli XCX. This is her moment to shine. And while Wallsocket still holds the place in my heart for her best album, U shows that she can still be herself even when aiming in a more pop oriented direction which keeps me rooting for her rise as a star.
Final Score: 7/10